Key developments since May 2005: The amount of land cleared and
reduced by HALO Trust in 2005―more than 2.5 square kilometers―was a
record for the organization’s program in Abkhazia. During 2005, HALO
declared the Gali region and the Gumista river valley near Sukhum mine
impact-free. In 2005, 15 new mine/UXO casualties were reported, a significant
increase from 2004 (six casualties).
Mine Ban Policy
Abkhazia is not an internationally recognized state, so it cannot become
party to the Mine Ban Treaty. After the disintegration of the Soviet Union, the
1992-1993 conflict between Abkhazia and Georgia was characterized by significant
use of mines by both sides. A cease-fire agreement was reached in May 1994, but
skirmishes have continued.
Officials have expressed sympathy with humanitarian concerns surrounding
landmines, but bluntly stated that Abkhazia cannot ban antipersonnel mines at
this time. In May 2005, the Foreign Minister told Landmine Monitor,
“Abkhazia suffered great losses because of landmines, and Abkhazia is
interested in solving the landmine crisis around the world. Our problem is that
we live under constant pressure of another war. Abkhazia cannot refuse to use
landmines, because it is one of the means of defense of its forces. When we
have international guarantees that there will be no war, then we will make
significant steps to join the Ottawa
Convention.”[1]
In March 2006, the Foreign Minister told Landmine Monitor that there had been
some progress in negotiations with Georgia on the security situation in the
upper part of Kodori valley, which allowed humanitarian demining to begin in the
area in 2006.[2]
Abkhazia is not believed to have ever produced or exported antipersonnel
mines. Abkhazian forces maintain a stockpile of antipersonnel mines, though its
size and composition is unknown. Russian engineering units serving with
Commonwealth of Independent States peacekeeping forces may also stockpile
antipersonnel mines.
There were no reports of use of antipersonnel mines by any armed forces in
Abkhazia during 2005 or early 2006. In May 2005, military officials told
Landmine Monitor, “There are special units in Abkhazia that are ready to
install landmine fields at any moment providing it is necessary for the defense
of national security.” They said the military forces of Abkhazia had not
used landmines for the past two
years.[3]
On 21 June 2006, President Sergei Bagapsh threatened to mine the border with
Georgia if Russian peacekeepers were withdrawn from the
area.[4] The ICBL sent a letter to
the President expressing concern about the statement and urging Abkhazia to
refrain from any new
mine-laying.[5]
Landmine and UXO Problem
Contamination of Abkhazia with mines and unexploded ordnance (UXO) resulted
from the armed conflict of 1992-1993 between the breakaway republic and Georgia
proper. The war was “characterized by front lines moving along the Black
Sea coast from the Gumista River, north of the city of Sukhum, to the Ingur
River further south.... Mines were laid in flat and fertile valleys to augment
the natural obstacles of the
rivers.”[6] In an interview in
May 2005, the Deputy Minister of Defense claimed that there were no mines left
on the border with Georgia.[7] During
2005, the HALO Trust completed clearance operations in the Gali region and the
Gumista river valley near
Sukhum.[8]
There is confirmed mine and UXO contamination in the Kodori
valley.[9] In previous years, HALO
had noted that due to insecurity and lawlessness in the valley, it was not
possible to conduct survey or mine clearance operations. During the latter half
of 2005, however, HALO was given unrestricted access to the Abkhaz-controlled
lower Kodori valley, where it carried out extensive survey and marking of the
mine contamination.[10]
Mine Action Program
There is no national mine action authority in Abkhazia. Mine action data
collection, planning and operational coordination continues to be provided by
the Abkhaz Mine Action Centre (AMAC), which was established by HALO in
1999.[11] Coordination of
HALO’s activities is arranged through Irakli Alasania, the President of
Georgia’s special representative to
Abkhazia[12] and by Sergey Shamba,
who serves as de facto Minister of Foreign Affairs of
Abkhazia.[13]
HALO manages AMAC, with funding from the US Department of State. AMAC
records all survey, clearance and post-clearance data. It is not clear to what
extent AMAC is able to manage mine action autonomously. As there is little
pressure on land in Abkhazia, task selection and prioritization are left largely
to the HALO management team, which liaises with local community leaders and the
Abkhaz authorities. All known minefields in Abkhazia have been prioritized for
clearance, with minefields closest to human habitation determined as the first
priorities.[14]
Evaluations of Mine Action
During 2005, AMAC and the HALO mine action program in Abkhazia were evaluated
on two separate visits by representatives of the US Department of
State.[15] The Department of State
found that, “The program was considered to be efficient, well-run and on
course to declare Abkhazia mine-safe during
2007.”[16] HALO’s mine
risk education (MRE) program is evaluated on an annual basis by the donor,
Entreaide Protestante Suisse. HALO also has a system of internal evaluations
and the program was visited three times by the HALO Caucasus and Balkans desk
officer; these visits provide strategic direction to the program as well as
carrying out internal auditing and checking. The HALO program in Abkhazia was
also externally audited twice during 2005 by international
auditors.[17]
Demining
HALO is the only demining operator in Abkhazia. It has been working in
Abkhazia since 1997, and has a clearly defined workplan and set of
priorities.[18] HALO deploys
integrated manual and mechanical mine clearance teams, MRE teams, and survey and
minefield marking teams, based in Ochamchire and Gali. The accelerated demining
program relies on additional mechanical clearance assets being deployed in
support of existing manual deminers.[19] HALO also operates two explosive ordnance disposal (EOD) teams, which
scour the countryside for
UXO.[20]
The objective of HALO’s accelerated demining program is to declare
Abkhazia “mine and UXO impact free, where security permits” by
mid-2007. HALO’s staff in Abkhazia are reported as being highly trained
and motivated and HALO is confident that it can finish its mission within two
years, provided the program maintains current funding
levels.[21]
Identification of Mined Areas: Surveys and Assessments
HALO conducted a comprehensive survey in 1999-2000 that identified nearly 18
square kilometers of land as being mined or suspected of being
mined.[22] It has since cleared and
area-reduced more than 10 square kilometers of this total. During 2005, 1.4
million square meters were reduced using armored
loaders.[23] During the latter half
of 2005, HALO carried out extensive survey and marking of the mine problem in
the lower Kodori valley.[24] It
found more than two square kilometers of suspect area, which it planned to start
clearing in 2006.[25]
During 2005, HALO made an agreement with the Abkhaz authorities for the use
of a helicopter for emergency evacuations from minefields. This allowed HALO to
change from using ambulances as their primary means of casualty evacuation, and
allowed technical survey teams to work further away from their vehicles. HALO
Abkhazia has three teams of technical surveyors who work ahead of the manual
teams to delineate mine lines and to reduce the suspect
area.[26]
Fencing and Marking
According to the UN, 95 percent of the minefields have been mapped and 80
percent have been marked by HALO.[27] HALO uses metal posts set in concrete with the international mine action
standards (IMAS) red triangle welded to the post. This marking may be modified
in the future to mark steep mountain slopes or mountain tops where it is
impossible to demine areas that may contain only one or two
mines.[28]
Mine and UXO Clearance
With significant funding from the US Department of State, 2005 proved to be
the most successful year to date for HALO in Abkhazia, with more land released
(2,563,950 square meters) and more mines (1,531 antipersonnel mines, 71
antivehicle mines) and UXO (1,794) destroyed than any other year of the
program.[29] During 2004, HALO had
manually demined 1,166,861 square meters and mechanically reduced 1,105,791
square meters of suspect area, with 708 antipersonnel mines, 115 antivehicle
mines and 869 UXO destroyed.[30]
Area (square meters) Cleared and Reduced, and Mines/UXO destroyed by HALO in
Abkhazia in 2005[31]
Mine clearance
Antipersonnel mines
Antivehicle mines
UXO
Area reduced or cancelled
1,147,024
1,531
71
1,794
1,416,926
Also during 2005, two highly significant milestones were achieved, with HALO
declaring the Gali region and the Gumista river valley near Sukhum mine
impact-free.[32] Work in both of
these areas took over seven years to complete. The lessons learnt will be used
to help HALO and the local authorities finish mine clearance in Abkhazia during
2007.[33]
A HALO deminer was injured by a mine during demining in Sukhum district on 15
August 2005.[34] The deminer
received a full insurance payout. All HALO staff are insured in the United
Kingdom.[35]
Mine action in Abkhazia relies heavily on the good weather and long days of
summer. During the summer months, the program employed more than 550 staff
which cleared mines and UXO in some of the most difficult minefields remaining.
During the accelerated phase of the program, a double shift system is used and
demining continues seven days a week. Overtime is paid for extended working
hours and each piece of capital equipment is used by two shifts, thereby
optimizing efficiency and
productivity.[36]
HALO Abkhazia deploys sections of up to eight deminers under the control of a
section commander, who checks each demining site at least four times a day. The
sections deploy as part of a larger demining team under the command of a field
officer who is responsible for all the demining sections working in the
minefield; the field officer checks each demining lane at least twice a day,
and, according to HALO standing operating procedures, checks to the end of each
lane at the end of each working day. Demining supervisors visit each minefield
checking the quality of demining and report back to the program manager who is
ultimately responsible for the quality of mine
clearance.[37]
Demined land is handed over to the local authorities in an official ceremony.
Representatives from the Ministry of Land Management and HALO staff walk over
the cleared area with local beneficiaries. A clearance certificate is signed by
the beneficiaries, the authorities and the HALO program
manager.[38] When HALO finishes
demining in a region of Abkhazia, it seeks independent verification that there
are no remaining minefields or suspect areas. Before HALO finished its
operations in the Gali region, the UN Observer Mission in Georgia (UNOMIG)
carried out an independent survey on HALO’s behalf. HALO and UNOMIG also
organized two public meetings, which were attended by all the village
administrators from Gali, representatives of NGOs and international
organizations.[39]
In 2006 and 2007, HALO aimed to finish demining in the Ochamchire region, the
mountains outside Sukhum and the Kodori
valley.[40] A significant amount of
work also remains in the Gumista river valley and around the holy sites at
Kaman, where demining was planned to start in 2006. It was hoped that
operations in the Tsugurovka and Habiuk mountains would be finished by the end
of the 2006 demining season.[41]
In May 2006, a HALO program update for January-April 2006 reported that,
“after a funding crisis earlier in the year,” it expected to declare
the Ochamchire region mine impact-free by the end of August. During the first
four months of 2006, HALO demined 401,282 square meters of land, destroying 143
antipersonnel mines, three antivehicle mines and 287 items of
UXO.[42]
Mine Risk Education
HALO conducts mine risk education in Abkhazia, as part of its integrated mine
action program.[43] Although the
reduction in casualties (six recorded) in 2004 has been linked to MRE, in 2005,
the number of mine/UXO casualties more than doubled to
15.[44]
HALO’s MRE teams maintain a casualty database; they have interviewed
the 532 survivors, as well as the families of the 150 people killed in mine/UXO
incidents in order to determine the exact location and cause of the incidents.
This information is used to analyze casualty trends and to adapt MRE activities.
The sites of the incidents are also checked by EOD and survey teams to ensure
that no dangerous items remain in the
area.[45]
As demining and EOD progresses, the MRE teams have adapted their approach to
encourage using cleared land.[46] In cooperation with Abkhaz authorities, HALO undertook an information
campaign on Abkhaz television encouraging people to return to their homes. The
information campaign also encouraged “former combatants who laid mines in
the valley to come forward and show HALO where they laid
mines.”[47]
Funding and Assistance
HALO’s operations in Abkhazia received about US$3,253,162 in mine
action assistance in 2005; the United States contributed $3 million and the
Netherlands donated €203,359
($253,162).[48] In 2004, HALO
received less―about $2 million―from more donors (the US,
Netherlands, UK, and Tokyo Broadcasting Systems/Association for Aid and Relief
Japan).[49]
The European Commission (EC), in its 2005-2007 mine action strategy,
envisaged providing assistance for MRE, fencing and marking in
Abkhazia.[50] It had previously
considered funding mine survey and clearance activities in Abkhazia during its
2002-2004 strategy.[51] No funding
had been provided by the end of 2005.
In May 2006, HALO reported a “funding crisis earlier in the
year,” but that operations continued with funding from the US Department
of State and the
Netherlands.[52]
Landmine/UXO Casualties
In 2005, HALO reported 15 new casualties in four landmine/UXO incidents,
including three killed and 12 injured. At least three children were among the
casualties as well as five military personnel and one HALO deminer. This is a
significant increase in casualties compared to 2004 when six people were
injured.[53]
On 16 November 2005, residents of the Gali region were traveling by lorry
through Kokhora village when they hit an antivehicle mine; two passengers were
badly injured and received initial treatment at a local hospital, while the
driver died at the scene.[54] A
group of Abkhaz soldiers tampered with a rocket from their own stores to use the
explosives for fishing, and in the resulting explosion, two soldiers were killed
and three injured. HALO provided emergency medical treatment and transportation
to the hospital. Two other incidents were the result of a dispute and attempted
extortion with antivehicle mines in the village of Kokhora, Ochamchire region;
seven people were injured, including several children who were traveling on
tractors when the mines
exploded.[55]
No new casualties in 2006 were reported as of May.
HALO has recorded 682 mine/UXO casualties between 1992 and the end of 2005,
150 people were killed and 532
injured.[56]
Survivor Assistance, Disability Policy and Practice
The system run by the Ministry of Health and Social Security in Abkhazia,
inherited from the Soviet era, was designed to provide comprehensive medical and
social services to all people with disabilities. Health facilities in Abkhazia
are in poor condition due to lack of resources. However, with improving
economic conditions, the Ministry of Health has gradually increased support for
medical facilities and a 20 percent increase in spending on disability was
registered in 2006.[57]
Médecins Sans Frontières provides emergency medical care and
surgical equipment in support of health facilities in Abkhazia, including a
clinic in Sukhum, as one of its two main
programs.[58] Landmine and other
war-related trauma is primarily treated in Agudzera Military Hospital. People
from the Kodori valley are also treated
there.[59]
Fourteen NGOs worked on disability issues in the reporting period, and
landmine survivors actively participated in seven of
them.[60] The two main Abkhazian
organizations are the Gagra Orthopedic Center and the Sukhum-based Association
of Invalid Support (Association Inva-Sodeistvie,
AIS).[61]
The Ministry of Health-run Gagra Orthopedic Center provides physical
rehabilitation services and orthopedic devices free of charge. It also has an
outreach service, for people living in the Gali area. The International
Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) provides materials and components, and a
one-month refresher course on management of lower-limb amputees. A seminar was
also organized in 2005 with the aim of finding ways for the authorities to
assume greater responsibility for the management of
services.[62] In 2005, the center
produced 80 prostheses (41 for mine survivors) and 38 orthoses, and distributed
11 wheelchairs and 520 crutches.[63] Many amputees, particularly those with above-knee amputations, have
reportedly sought orthopedic assistance in Armenia and
Russia.[64] The Ministry of Health
increased support for medical facilities and contributed $6,500 of the $40,000
needed annually for the center’s operations. In 2006, the Ministry of
Health assumed full financial responsibility for management of the center; the
ICRC continued to provide material for prosthetic
production.[65]
AIS aims to promote a social, rights-based approach to disability issues. It
provides physical rehabilitation, psychosocial support and computer classes for
mine survivors and other people with disabilities, and began developing a
disability database for Abkhazia in 2006. AIS’s physical rehabilitation
activities are implemented in cooperation with the Center for Humanitarian
Programs and Agudzera Republican Hospital. In cooperation with the European
Commission, AIS conducted medium-term projects on inclusive education and
“wheelchair diplomacy” in
Abkhazia.[66]
The Verask Charitable Foundation for the Disabled and Amputees, supported by
Adopt-A-Minefield, provides mobility devices to mine survivors and other people
with disabilities in Abkhazia. In 2005, Verask distributed 30 wheelchairs, 80
crutches, 80 walking sticks, and provided financial assistance to 20 people with
disabilities in the Gali
region.[67]
The Harmony Center for Psychological Help, with the support of UNICEF and
HALO, implements a summer rehabilitation program for child mine survivors and
their families. In 2006, HALO MRE personnel will take part in the
activities.[68]
The Ministry of Health and Social Security is responsible for assistance to
disabled people in Abkhazia. The Medical and Social Expertise Commission
operates a database and collects data from regional commissions throughout
Abkhazia, and people with disabilities receive treatment based on their needs,
as established by the local commissions. The benefits are reportedly
small.[69] There is a general
tendency in Abkhazia to treat people with disabilities from an inclusive and
socially oriented point of
view.[70]
A new law to protect the rights of people with disabilities was drafted with
input from disability organizations and people with disabilities, one of whom
was elected as a member of
parliament.[71] As of May 2006, the
legislation had not been approved. Alhas Thagushev, former director of AIS and
member of parliament, stated that, “any new legislation in this field has
to be relevant to existing social infrastructure, governing system and necessary
financial support. A number of new laws have been drafted including on social
security and at the moment they are considered by the parliamentary
commissions.”[72]
The Coordination Council on the Issues of Disabled in Abkhazia, a coalition
of government and NGOs, was established to address the needs of people with
disabilities, including landmine survivors; the council was inactive in 2005,
and reportedly remained inactive to May 2006, due to changes in government
structures.[73]
[1] Interview with Sergey Shamba,
Minister of Foreign Affairs, Sukhum, 23 May 2005. Military officials echoed
similar sentiments: “Landmines in Abkhazia are used for the purpose of
defense of her military personnel, and at this moment we cannot refuse to use
this weapon.” Interview with Lt. Gen. Anatoly Zaitsev, Deputy Minister of
Defense and Chief of General Staff, and Col. Garry Kupalba, Deputy Minister of
Defense, Sukhum, 24 May 2005. [2] Interview with Sergey Shamba,
Minister of Foreign Affairs, Sukhum, 23 March 2006. [3] Interview with Lt. Gen. Anatoly
Zaitsev, Ministry of Defense, and Col. Garry Kupalba, Ministry of Defense,
Sukhum, 24 May 2005. Abkhazia last acknowledged using antipersonnel mines in
mid-2002. See Landmine Monitor Report 2004, p. 1180. [4] At a press conference, the
President stated that there is no alternative to Russian peacekeepers in the
zone of conflict, and if Georgia continues to insist on their withdrawal,
Abkhazia will withdraw from the negotiations. He said, “I assure you that
the attitude to the border will be different than it is today. There will be
100 percent mining of the border...according to international rules.”
(Translation by Landmine Monitor), www.regnum.ru/news/660767.html.
Another Abkhazian official, Kristian Bjania, representative of the President,
confirmed the remarks about use of mines. Email from Abkhazian Campaign to Ban
Landmines, 4 July 2006. Georgian media also reported on the Abkhazian
president’s remarks. See news.gpb.ge/english/det.html?id=3178&dateg=21-06-2006. [5] ICBL website, “ICBL Urges
Abkhazia not to lay new mines,” www.icbl.org, accessed 11 July 2006. [6] See Landmine Monitor Report
2005, pp. 933-934. [7] Ibid. [8] HALO Trust, “The HALO
Trust Mine Clearance Programme Abkhazia, Activity Report 2005,” pp. 2,
9. [9] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006, provided by email from David McMahon, Program
Manager, HALO Trust Abkhazia, 21 February 2006. Contamination in that area had
previously been claimed by local authority representatives. See Landmine
Monitor Report 2005, p. 934. [10] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006; email from Matthew Hovell, Caucasus and Balkans
Desk Officer, HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [11] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, pp. 934-935. [12] Response by HALO to Landmine
Monitor Mine Action Questionnaire, 26 February 2006. [13] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [14] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, pp. 934-935. [15] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [16] Email from David McMahon,
HALO, Abkhazia, 17 May 2006. [17] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [18] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006. [19] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, pp. 934-935. [20] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006. [21] Ibid. According to
HALO’s annual report for 2005, however, “It was HALO’s
intention to declare Abkhazia mine-impact free by the summer of 2007, but due to
reduced funding this end date may have to change.” HALO, “The HALO
Trust Mine Clearance Programme Abkhazia, Activity Report 2005,” p. 9. [22] Landmine Monitor Report
2005, p. 934. [23] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [24] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006. [25] Response by HALO to Landmine
Monitor Mine Action Questionnaire, 26 February 2006. [26] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [27] UN, “Country Profile:
Georgia,” www.mineaction.org,
accessed 11 March 2006. [28] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [29] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006. [30] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, p. 935. [31] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. Slightly lower clearance figures quoted in
HALO’s report on activities in 2005 are for the year to the beginning of
December. Email from David McMahon, HALO, Abkhazia, 18 May 2006. [32] HALO, “The HALO Trust
Mine Clearance Programme Abkhazia, Activity Report 2005,” pp. 2, 9. [33] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006. [34] Response by HALO to Landmine
Monitor Mine Action Questionnaire, 26 February 2006. [35] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [36] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006. [37] Email from Matthew Hovell,
HALO, Scotland, 24 April 2006. [38] Ibid. [39] Ibid. [40] “HALO Abkhazia 2005
Update,” February 2006. [41] Response by HALO to Landmine
Monitor Mine Action Questionnaire, 26 February 2006. [42] HALO Abkhazia,
“Programme Update (January to April 2005 [sic]),” 16 May
2006, p. 1. [43] HALO, “The HALO Trust
Mine Clearance Programme Abkhazia, Activity Report 2005,” p. 6; for
details of MRE in Abkhazia, see Landmine Monitor Report 2005, p. 936;
Landmine Monitor Report 2004, p. 1183. [44] HALO, “The HALO Trust
Mine Clearance Programme Abkhazia, Activity Report 2005,” p. 6. [45] HALO, “The HALO Trust
Mine Clearance Programme Abkhazia, Activity Report 2005,” p. 6. [46] Interview with Julie Agumaa,
Mine Awareness Coordinator, HALO Abkhazia, Tamish Village, 23 March 2006. [47] HALO Abkhazia,
“Programme Update (January to April 2005 [sic]),” 16 May
2006. [48] USG Historical Chart
containing data for FY 2004, email from Angela L. Jeffries, Financial Management
Specialist, US Department of State, 20 July 2005; email from Ellen Schut,
Arms Control and Arms Export Policy Division, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 7
April 2006; email from Brechtje Paardekooper, DMV/HH Humanitarian Aid Division,
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 18 April 2006. Average exchange rate for 2005:
€1 = US$1.2449. US Federal Reserve, “List of Exchange Rates
(Annual),” 3 January 2006. [49] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, p. 936. Tokyo Broadcasting Systems/Association of Aid and
Relief Japan (AAR/J), completed their four-year funding project with HALO in
April 2005. Email from Seiji Konno, AAR/J, 23 May 2006. [50] EC, “The European
Roadmap Towards a Zero Victim Target: The EC Mine Action Strategy &
Multi-annual Indicative Programming 2005-2007,” p. 38. [51] EC, “EC Mine Action
2002-2004,” p. 16; EC, “EC Mine Action 2005-2007,” p. 38. [52] HALO Abkhazia,
“Programme Update (January to April 2005 [sic]),” 16 May
2006, p. 1. [53] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, p. 937. [54] “An Anti-Tank Mine
Explosion Wounds Two Persons In Gali District,” Prime News Online
(Tbilisi), 16 November 2005. [55] Email from David McMahon,
HALO, Abkhazia, 4 May 2006. [56] HALO, “The HALO Trust
Mine Clearance Programme Abkhazia, Activity Report 2005,” March 2006, p.
7. [57] Interview with Olga
Koltukova, Minister of Labor and Social Security, Sukhum, 30 March 2006;
interview with Zurab Marshania, Minister of Health, Sukhum, 25 May 2006;
interview with Leonid Lakerbaya, Deputy Prime Minister, Sukhum, 26 March
2006. [58] “Report of the UN
Secretary-General on the situation in Abkhazia, Georgia,” S/2004/315, 20
April 2004, p. 7; interviews with Janthimala Price, Field Coordinator,
Médecins Sans Frontières, Sukhum, 27 March and 1 June 2006. [59] Interview with Dr. Guram
Shoua, Agudzera Military Hospital, Agudzera, 26 March 2006. [60] AIS, “Guide on Local
and International NGOs Working in Abkhazia,” Sukhum, 2005. [61] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, p. 937. [62] ICRC Physical Rehabilitation
Program, “Annual Report 2005,” Geneva, draft received 19 May 2006,
p. 29. [63] Interviews with Owsia Zarvan
Raniero, Head of ICRC Mission to Abkhazia, Sukhum, 29 March and 31 May 2006;
ICRC Physical Rehabilitation Program, “Annual Report 2005,” Geneva,
draft received 19 May 2006, p. 29. [64] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, p. 938. [65] Interview with Zurab
Marshania, Minister of Health, Sukhum, 16 May 2006; interview with Owsia Zarvan
Raniero, Head of ICRC Mission to Abkhazia, Sukhum, 12 May 2006. [66] Interviews with Aslan
Kutsnia, Advocacy Director, AIS, Sukhum, 30 March 2006 and 4 May 2006. [67] Telephone interview with
Victoria Dumaa, Director, Verask Charitable Foundation, Sukhum, 31 May 2006. [68] Interview with Victoria
Ardzinba, Director, Harmony Center, Sukhum, 4 May 2006. [69] Interview with Olga
Koltukova, Minister of Labor and Social Security, Sukhum, 30 March 2006. [70] Interview with Aslan
Kutsnia, AIS, Sukhum, 30 May 2006. [71] See Landmine Monitor
Report 2005, p. 938. [72] Interview with Alkhas
Tkhagushev, AIS, Sukhum, 16 April 2006. [73] Interview with Aslan
Kutsnia, AIS, Sukhum, 30 March 2006.